Could You Date Someone Who “Used to Be” Gay?
I'm a 23-year-old Black male living in the South. I just finished my first year of grad school and I'll have completed two graduate degrees by next year. I work and I'm pretty much independent. I'm always reading about the shortage of good Black men, and I think it's garbage. I consider myself a good man, and I think I could really make some woman happy.
People always say how good-looking, intelligent, nice, and fun to be around I am and then they always give me a funny look and wonder what's wrong with me because I don't have a girlfriend. I always resort to the fact that aside from class, work, and Wal-Mart I'm pretty much locked inside the library or my apartment. This is true for the most part, but I always fail to reveal the fact that I have a more than friendly past with other Black men.
When I first began college a few months before my 18th birthday, I began dating men and I did so off and on up until I turned 22. I've never had sex with a man (or a woman because I'm actually against pre-marital sex—go figure), but I've kissed and fondled my share of men.
Long story short, I finally stopped dealing with guys around the time I turned 22 because I wasn't finding what I was looking for, which, after counseling and a few familial blowouts, I realized that I was just looking to be loved by a man because I'd never experienced that. My father and I only recently began being cordial to one another. He was always there for me financially, but he never spent any time with me and he didn't hug me or tell me he loved me until I was almost killed by a gang of robbers at 22.
Although I was angry at him for doing these things under the circumstances that he did, it was the most amazing hug I'd ever gotten in my life and I'd be lying if I said I wasn't happy because for the first time in my life I felt as if my dad was actually my "dad" and not some adversarial human ATM machine and that I really was important to him and that he really did love me and want me as a son.
Although I realized long before I approached the age of 22 that I wasn't really attracted to men, I continued to date them because it was what I knew. I knew how to talk to men and how to play all of their games and I enjoyed it until it became serious and they wanted more than friendship and a warm handshake from me.
I had a way of attracting great guys that were well educated, well paid, handsome, and decent people and getting them all wrapped up in me and then telling them that I couldn't be with them. To be honest, the thought of being in a relationship or having sex with a man scares the hell out of me. When I was younger, I enjoyed masturbating with men because it amazed me that other guys could be so much like me (I'm a weird narcissistic guy), but that soon grew old and seemed really immature to me. I've never had one romantic or sexual dream about a man, and when I think of being in love, I always see a woman.
Early on I worried about what my family and society in general would think of my being bisexual, but eventually I got over that and began making preparations to come out of the closet. I "came out" to a few friends and relatives, only to realize that I'd made a big mistake. It's very easy to come out of the closet, but it's impossible to say "just kidding" and go on with your life, especially if you're a man and Black.
My issue is that I've been discouraged from seriously dating women for fear that they will somehow find out about my past dealings with men. I've talked to girls that I've told about my past (mostly bisexual girls) and they've all said that they would never date a bisexual guy or a man that has ever been interested in men because they felt he would always be gay, which I found strange seeing as how they are themselves bisexual and actively involved with females.
I took Psych 101 and I've known a lot of bisexual girls so I understand that women's sexuality is more changeable than men's. But I think the operative phrase here is "more changeable" because it implies that men's sexuality can in fact change. I've even joked with girls that I've dated about it and they've said things to the tune of "I'd f*ck up his life if I found out a guy I was dating was gay." Ironically, these are girls that have dated guys that I know for a fact are or have been involved sexually and romantically with other men.
So, you see, I'm stuck in a way because I honestly like women and I want to be with one in every way and eventually get married and have kids, but I feel branded. I've lost really close friends because they couldn't accept me after I decided to be real with myself and leave the gay lifestyle. I never thought I'd be in this situation, because truthfully I never thought all of this was a big deal. I mean, I always knew I wasn't gay and when I made up my mind to stop playing myself and guys crazy enough to seriously like me, I thought all would be cool. But I never really thought that people would forever see me as gay (according to the popular opinion, you're either a straight man or a gay man and if you're gay you can never not be).
Right now I'm biding my time until I move to a different city or state and get a chance to start over, but even then I feel as if I should tell any woman that I seriously date about my past because you never know who you may run into along the way and I've pissed off a lot of guys who would love to ruin me. Maybe I wouldn't tell her right off, but rather soon after things became serious between us.
I'd just like to know what people think, especially women. We talk a lot about bisexual men, but what about bisexual men who are no longer interested in men. I know it's something that we never hear much about, but I know I'm not the only one. I have to say that I'm not confused about my sexuality either. I think I've tested it enough to know for sure who I am.
Dear Mr. Curious,Thanks for sharing your story as I'm sure it took a lot to write this. With all honesty my initial thought is that you're (still) struggling with sexual identity based on your (non-sexual) interaction with men but I'll not fall in to the trap of judging or boxing in someone that's reached out for help/advice. With that said, I'll take you at your word.
Unfortunately, as you've already experienced, not many other people will do the same. As much as you view yourself as such "a good Black man," from my experience most women won't because of your past. You say that you've been discouraged from seriously dating women for fear that they will somehow find out about your past dealings with men and with good cause. I've seen and heard it way too many times from women scared that their man is on the DL so to be with a man that's admittedly been with other men (albeit non sexually) is a big red flag and leaves concern of a "relapse." Chances are they won't even believe that you didn't have sex.
What I find most interesting though is you're reasoning for dating men. You say it was your way of getting the love your father never gave you, but there are many men (myself included) that didn't have a father that filled that void much differently. Sure you didn't have sex with them but you admit to doing a lot of things the average straight man would not—father or no father. That's not to totally negate your rationale for your actions but just providing you with the general public response to your reasoning for dating men.
The one thing I wonder is if your (religious?) views on premarital sex were different would you have gone all the way with a guy? Did you ever have any feelings at all for these men and feel "love"? You say you realized a long time ago that you really weren't attracted to men but yet in still you continued to date them because that's "what you knew." I'm sorry, that seems like a major contradiction and leads me to believe you are (or were?) confused about your sexual identity. Again, people who are sure about what they want in regards to heterosexuality don't make a habit of kissing and fondling people they're not attracted to. It's not like a guy messing with an "ugly" girl because even then he may not be attracted to her physically but he's clearly still attracted to women.
However you rationalize your past and categorize yourself now bottom line is you have to be happy with yourself. That's all that matters. I'm sure it hurt when people you knew shunned you for revealing your past but I hope that didn't cause you to internally shun who you know you are deep down inside.
That brings up another question. I noticed you're adamant about leaving the gay “lifestyle,” but later on you identify yourself as bisexual. Seems like another contradiction as that label would denote someone that's attracted to both sexes. However, you say you're "not really" attracted to men even though your past actions and carrying of bisexual title would suggest otherwise. Also, being gay/lesbian isn't a lifestyle it's a way of life that people are born in to, IMHO. Just takes some longer for some to accept that due mostly to society.
You seem to have a lot of bi friends. Is that so you can be closer to the community and people that share your experiences/emotions? Maybe that's a subconscious coincidence but something to consider.
It was also unclear if you've ever dated a (non bi) woman at all. You said school and a hectic schedule made that difficult but you still found time to date men. Just curious to know if your entire dating life has been male or not as if that's the case it weakens your argument of not being gay or at the very least bisexual. Not that there's anything wrong with that. It's okay to experiment in your youth if you’re bi-curios just understand that not everyone will agree with that but that's their problem not yours. You have to do what makes you happy at all times (as long as it's legal).
If you truly were just experimenting with men and realized it's not right for you for whatever reason, moving may be a good idea since you revealed so much of yourself to people in your current circle and their negative reaction. To move on from the "branding" you may just have to start from scratch elsewhere or move to a place where that sort of thing is not looked down upon and folks are more liberal.
As for revealing your past to the women you date that'll really be a case-by-case basis. Not every person you date needs to know about every single thing in your past (especially in the beginning stages) but if a relationship was evolving to marriage maybe that might be something to share with someone you plan to spend the rest of your life with. Again, you just have to be ready to expect and accept a negative reaction from some based on their own beliefs.
I imagine it's a hard cross to bear but I wish you luck. They say there's someone for every one and I believe while there are many women that will give you side-eye there's plenty who will be able to look past your past—especially if you're truly sure about who you are sexually and not just in denial. Either way be proud of your past because it made you who you are today. Others can only accept it or not.
Do you feel a bisexual man is always branded as being gay? Does the same apply to a bisexual woman? Why or why not? Do you view the belief that this man made out with men because he was searching for the love he never got from his father as valid? Does the fact that he never had sex with a man make a difference in how you’d view him? Would you classify this man as gay, bisexual or bi curious? Do you think it’s possible for a man to experiment with other men and realize he’s not into it and be straight? Do you feel that most women would walk away from this man because of his past? Would the same apply to a woman with the same past? Is that fair? Do you think he’s still in the closet and in denial or has done enough experimenting to know who he is sexually?
Speak your piece…
- SOCK IT TO ME
- Purchase T-shirts, thongs & more in the NWSO Online Store
- “Like” the NWSO FaceBook Fan Page
- Follow NWSO’s rants on Twitter @NakedWithSocks
- Ask NWSO anything on FormSpring
- Have a question or wish to submit a guest post? Email NWSO: NakedWithSocksOn@gmail.com
-
http://strokeofprose.com Kaye Michele
-
Lyndon
-
sasha
-
chileboo
-
http://ladyngo.blogspot.com Lady Ngo
-
http://theworldoftiffany.wordpress.com Tiffany
-
OSHH
-
http://realestdudeintheroom.com RDITR
-
OSHH
-
Jermaine
-
Charnv48
-
Charnv48
-
Charnv48
-
Charnv48
-
justme
-
difficultisnotimpossible
-
Charnv48
-
Tenicia
-
http://wwwinmycomfortzone.blogspot.com Southern Poise
-
Rastaman
-
c0c0puffz
-
Starita34
-
FireIce
-
Bimbetta
-
lyndon
-
Wmofyr
-
Wmofyr
-
OSHH
-
jaclynsd
-
Miss Conception
-
Wmofyr
-
Potato-with_Jive
-
Da Son
-
Lyndon
-
justme
-
Mrs. Birghtside
-
Potato-with_Jive
-
Chellz
-
fay
-
SNS
-
Lonias
-
http://realestdudeintheroom.com RDITR
-
http://realestdudeintheroom.com RDITR
-
Mrs. Da ThRONe
-
FireIce
-
http://liferebirth.blogspot.com/ Rebirth
-
jaclynsd
-
http://www.nwso.net Gemini
-
http://queersyndicate.com Ask A Bisexual Guy
-
http://Nwso.net Gemini
-
Lyndon
-
da ThRONe
-
http://Nwso.net Gemini
-
http://realestdudeintheroom.com RDITR
-
jbreezy
-
jaclynsd
-
Artemis Fowl
-
Lonias
-
Wmofyr
-
Miss Conception
-
http://www.facebook.com/camille.c.crisp Camille C. Crisp
-
Auder
-
Auder
-
Charnv48
-
Charnv48
-
Charnv48
-
Charnv48
-
SassyNOLa
-
SassyNOLa
-
SassyNOLa
-
Anonymous
-
da ThRONe

